Supported by
Alternative Cancer Treatments May Be Bad for Your Health
People who used herbs, acupuncture and other complementary treatments tended to die earlier than those who didn’t.
Herbs, acupuncture and other so-called complementary treatments for cancer may not be completely innocuous.
A new study has found that many cancer patients treat these nostrums not as a supplement to conventional treatment, but as an alternative. This, the researchers say, can be dangerous.
The observational analysis, in JAMA Oncology, used data on 258 complementary medicine users and 1,032 people in a control group. Complementary therapies included herbs, vitamins, traditional Chinese medicine, homeopathy, naturopathy, yoga, acupuncture and others.
People who used complementary treatments were more often women, younger, privately insured and of higher socioeconomic status. They did not delay the start of conventional treatment any longer than others, but they had higher rates of refusal of surgery, chemotherapy, radiation and hormone treatments. They also had lower five-year survival rates, and more than double the risk of death.
The complementary treatments did no harm when conventional treatment was carried out simultaneously.
“Cancer treatment is scary,” said the senior author, James B. Yu, an associate professor of therapeutic radiology at Yale. “It’s a human response to seek out therapies that promise no side effects and only benefits. We need to listen to patients, and help them integrate these therapies with conventional therapy.
“Complementary medicines are supposed to help you endure treatment, but some believe they will help cure you. We found no evidence of that.”
A Guide to Supplements
Surveys suggest that more than half of Americans use some kind of supplement. But how effective are all those pills, powders and tinctures?
Several companies are now selling bovine colostrum as a supplement for humans, claiming several health benefits. Here’s what experts say.
Research suggests that a daily multivitamin can improve cognition. But that doesn’t mean everyone should take one.
Proponents of castor oil claim it can improve vision, reduce wrinkles, boost hair growth and more. Can it really do all that?
Some manufacturers claim that certain supplements can help you focus. Here is what the experts say.
Melatonin tricks your body into feeling like it’s time for bed, but it isn’t a sleeping pill. Here’s how to use it and why it might be tricky for regular users to fall asleep without it.
Can you distinguish the good supplements from the harmful or useless ones? Take our quiz.
Advertisement